When sleep won't come, many people grab whatever's in the medicine cabinet: ZzzQuil, Benadryl, Unisom or a “PM” pain reliever. They can help on an occasional night. But if you've started taking one most nights, it's worth knowing what's inside and how natural options compare.
What's actually in drugstore sleep aids
Most over-the-counter sleep aids rely on one of two sedating antihistamines:
- Diphenhydramine (as HCl or citrate): the active ingredient in ZzzQuil Nighttime Sleep-Aid, Benadryl and most “PM” products
- Doxylamine succinate: the active ingredient in Unisom SleepTabs
“PM” pain relievers pair the antihistamine with acetaminophen or ibuprofen. If you don't have pain, you're taking a pain reliever you don't need, and it's easy to double up on acetaminophen without realizing it.
How they work, and why they stop working
These antihistamines block histamine, a brain chemical that helps keep you awake, which makes you drowsy. They're labeled for occasional sleeplessness. According to the Mayo Clinic:
- Tolerance to their sleepy effect can develop quickly, so the longer you take them, the less likely they are to make you sleepy.
- Side effects can include daytime drowsiness, dry mouth, constipation and urinary retention.
- They aren't recommended for people with certain conditions, including closed-angle glaucoma, peptic ulcer and urinary retention.
- They may pose extra risks for people over 65, and they aren't intended for long-term use.
- They should never be mixed with alcohol.
Natural options, compared
| Option | How it's thought to work | What to know |
|---|---|---|
| Melatonin | Signals your body clock that it's night | Best for jet lag and schedule shifts; some people feel sleepy or foggy the next day |
| Magnesium | Supports general relaxation | Popular and gentle; research on sleep quality is mixed |
| L-theanine | Promotes a calm, unwound feeling | Relaxing without sedation |
| Valerian, chamomile | Classic calming herbs | Some studies show a benefit, others don't |
| Ashwagandha | Helps the body manage everyday stress | A 2021 meta-analysis found a small benefit for overall sleep, with larger effects in people with insomnia, at 600 mg a day or more, and over at least 8 weeks |
| Multi-botanical formulas | Combine calming and stress-support ingredients | Check standardization, the full serving and third-party testing |
Side by side: a diphenhydramine sleep aid vs. Speed Sleep
| Diphenhydramine sleep aid | Speed Sleep® | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Over-the-counter drug | Dietary supplement |
| Main ingredients | A sedating antihistamine | 12 standardized extracts, including ziziphus seed, ashwagandha and 5-HTP from griffonia |
| Built for | Occasional sleeplessness | Helping your mind wind down, night after night* |
| Tolerance | Can develop quickly | Formulated to be non-habit forming* |
| Melatonin | None | None added |
| How to take it | As labeled, for short-term use | 4 capsules about 30 minutes before bed |
Switching from a nightly antihistamine
- Talk to your pharmacist or doctor first, especially if you've used it nightly for a long time or take other medications.
- Expect a few adjustment nights. Sleep may feel lighter at first.
- Lean on habits: a fixed wake time, morning light, no late caffeine and a screen-free wind-down.
- Give your new routine two weeks before judging it.
Where Speed Sleep fits
If you've been relying on a drugstore sleep aid because your body is tired but your mind won't switch off, Speed Sleep® was built for that night.* There's no melatonin, no antihistamine and no added sugar. It's made in the USA in an NSF GMP-certified facility and tested by Eurofins, an ISO 17025-accredited lab, and the original formula won a 2025 Taste for Life Supplement Essentials Award. For the bigger picture, read Non-Habit-Forming Sleep Aids: What to Look For.
When to see a doctor
Over-the-counter sleep-aid labels tell you to ask a doctor if sleeplessness lasts more than two weeks. Also see a professional if you snore loudly, wake up gasping, or feel very sleepy during the day.
ZzzQuil, Benadryl and Unisom are trademarks of their respective owners; BNH is not affiliated with these brands. *These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease. Speed Sleep is not for use during pregnancy or breastfeeding. Talk with your doctor before use if you take medication, especially antidepressants or other medicines that affect serotonin.

